Manufacturing Dissent Since 1996
New interviews throughout the week

A Constitution against Oligarchy / William E. Forbath

The bosses of the senate by joseph keppler

The constitution as the framers imagined it, building on a long, English tradition, was something very different from ordinary law. And what happened over time is that the supreme court said that "no, the constitution is just like ordinary law, and we get to interpret it and what we say is binding." And then, in the coup de grace, liberals and progressives bought into that. For good reasons, and we can talk about those, but for reasons that are completely worn out. So no, the framers would be the first to say constitutional law is the law the people enforce over against their rulers. It's the opposite of ordinary law, that's the English tradition. We wrote it down in the U.S. to make it firmer, but not to give courts authority over it. The idea of judicial supremacy was something that was built up over the nineteenth century, and it was an idea that progressive over the nineteenth century and beyond always rejected.

Chuck interviews legal scholar William E. Forbath on the book "The Anti-Oligarchy Constitution" that he co-authored with Joseph Fishkin.

Share Tweet Send


Related Interviews
Steve Fraser
Sep 12 2022
1024px courtroom of the supreme court with associate justice ruth bader ginsburg s chair and the bench in front of her seat draped in black

SCOTUS v. Democracy / Steve Fraser

Jon Schwarz
Jun 29 2022
Second amendment sisters rally  may 2000  35725219

SCOTUS Fraud and the Second Amendment