Manufacturing Dissent Since 1996
New interviews throughout the week
Grazinao  medak photo

Different systems of care have emerged out of practices of caring for each other and struggling for that capacity to care to be expanded. Our interest in pirate care, we understand that there are systems of care that these days are being dismantled and that growing parts of the population are being denied the right to care that are essential to their survival. In response to that condition a number of initiatives of various sorts have emerged across the world to defy forms of exclusion and provide that necessary care for those who might not be citizens of a certain nation or who might not be able to pay up whatever markets are asking them to or do not have the family structure to support them in situations need.

Valeria Graziano, Marcell Mars and Tomislav Medak discuss their book, Pirate Care: Acts Against the Criminalization of Solidarity. "The Moment of Truth" with Jeff Dorchen and "Rotten History" by Renaldo Migaldi both follow the interview.

Help keep This Is Hell! completely listener supported and access bonus episodes by subscribing to our Patreon.

 


Jun 13 2023
Jun 12 2023
Posted by Alexander Jerri
Three loop ouroboros

There’s a vicious circle, or cycle, eating its own tail in the West. Here’s the mechanism: people protest, civilly disobey, subvert, argue, and generally struggle against a status quo that oppresses them. The status quo reacts, overcorrects to prevent not just the change but even the possibility to struggle for change. The resistance has to rebuild, refashion its tools, explore new options for struggle. By the time they’ve almost clawed their way back to their former visibility and power, the status quo has reiterated so many outrageous lies against the resistors’ counter-arguments that it forces them to reframe the discourse. But eventually even the reframing starts to suffer from the law of diminishing returns.

 

Meanwhile the status quo has pounded home the argument that “everyone’s sick of the resistance” and weaponizes whatever public opinion they can along those lines. This makes the resistance fight harder, resort to more rigidly doctrinaire arguments, harsher tactics, ad absurdum, which the status quo in its turn uses to further discredit them in the zeitgeist.

 

By this time, though, the status quo has divided into two sides: on one side blandly ineffectual representatives of the resistors, funded by the blandly ineffectual “reasonable” rich who water down the true resistance’s arguments, aims, and strategies; and on the other side, funded by openly undemocratic wealth hoarders and corporations, the ferocious and exciting cutting edge supercool badboy violent authoritarians who take discrediting of the resistance to utterly insane lengths. For the lulz. And money. They accuse their “enemies” of the most sexually perverse varieties of violence in order to justify the violence they themselves want to use to extinguish them.

Maybe the violence turns into a war. Or maybe it subsides for a time, though the root problems don’t get fixed, or get half-fixed at best, keeping hostilities kindled.

We’re at a moment where everybody’s just damn fed up with each other. Those in various groups on the left are fed up because they can’t believe they have to fight the same battles all over again. They shriek louder and fight harder because they want to make sure once and for all their grandchildren don’t also have to fight the same battles all over again.

 

Groups on the right are fed up because... read more